Ami,
I can talk only about Lakme as I have been using this since 2004...I tried 2 versions, one liquid liner and the other one with felt tip...you know what I am talking...
Now, I wish to change that........mine expired and I never want to buy Lakme again....no issues, but felt that Lakme makes my eyes a bit stiff...like I feel something strange and heavy on my eyes...may be the formula is heavy on me...
I am not sure whether to try Revlon Colorstay or Loreal Carbon black...
Lotus.....sorry, honey...I am hearing for the first time about this eyeliner...I didnt know Lotus makes color cosmetics...I only tried their lip balm...
D.